Montminy (
2016 TCC 110) is the first case to consider the interaction
between regulations 6204(1)(b) and 6204(2) (c). The TCC concluded
that the latter does not apply to negate the twoyear
reasonable holding period in the former.
Were the taxpayers in Montminy entitled to a deduction
whereby a CCPC employee defers the recognition of employment income
to the year when he or she disposes of the CCPC's shares
(paragraph 110(1)(d.1))? In conjunction with section 7, only half
of the taxable benefit (simulating a capital gain) is taxed
(paragraphs 110(1)(d) and 110(1)(d.1)). The 50 percent deduction is
allowed if the shares are prescribed under regulation 6204.
The taxpayers were employed at Cybectec, a tech company in the
competitive IT industry, which established a stock option plan in
2001 to retain employees. In 2007, Cybectec received an unsolicited
offer from Cooper Industrial Electrical Inc. to purchase all of its
shares; Cooper changed the offer to an offer to