My law firm cannot make the claim that we have won all of our
cases in the Tax Court of
Canada, but what we can tell you is that every single case
we have won in tax court — either in trial or a settlement
— was lost at the CRA objection stage. And in many cases,
besides losing our tax assessment
objection, we were also unable to convince a
CRA auditor of our client's position. In these types of
cases, two different Canada Revenue Agency departments had thought
we were wrong before we were able to convince a judge otherwise. So
before a win or settlement in tax court, the taxpayer often has to
lose twice.
After notices of objection fail, people ask us whether it is
worth fighting their case in tax court. After a loss, many
taxpayers simply roll over and accept that the CRA was right
— but the tax agency is often wrong.