ABSTRACT
This paper provides analysis of one of the foundational elements
of the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) and various
intergovernmental agreements (IGAs): an unambiguous place of U.S.
birth and the ability to cure (Cure) this element, thereby
rendering the account nonreportable. The IGAs generally allow the
individual to Cure his unambiguous place of U.S. birth by producing
a Certificate of Loss of Nationality (CLN) or by providing a
"reasonable explanation" of why he does not have one
despite having relinquished U.S. citizenship.
Unfortunately, however, none of the IGAs, FATCA, or legislative
history provide guidance as to what might constitute a
"reasonable explanation." Analysis of this issue is
deceptively difficult because (beginning in 2004) U.S. law
differentiated the loss of U.S. citizenship for nationality
purposes from the loss of U.S. citizenship for tax purposes.
Further, FATCA and the IGAs use the tax definition of U.S.
citizenship