Double N Earthmovers Ltd. v. Edmonton (City of) (S.C.C.)
In the recent case of Double N Earthmovers Ltd. v. Edmonton (City of), the Supreme Court of Canada considered the scope of an owner’s obligation to treat all bidders fairly during the tender process.
In this case, the City of Edmonton initiated a tender for a contract to supply equipment and operators to remove refuse from a city landfill. As part of the tender specifications, the City requested that the equipment must be 1980 or newer. The bidders were required to provide serial numbers and licence registration numbers for the equipment to be used.
When the tenders were opened, the City determined that Sureway Construction Ltd. ("Sureway") and the plaintiff, Double N Earthmovers Ltd. ("Double N") were the first and second lowest compliant tenders. Subsequently, the City engaged in discussions with both Sureway and Double N regarding their bids. The City ultimately awarded the contract to Sureway. After being awarded the