Production Order Challenge Results In Recognition Of Duty To Assert Consumer Privacy Rights

​Sproat J. of the Superior Court of Justice has issued a very important decision for organizations that find themselves subject to a search warrant or production order seeking personal information in their records about third parties.

Overview

On January 14th, 2016, in R. v. Rogers Communications, Sproat J. of the Superior Court of Justice issued a very important decision for organizations that find themselves subject to a search warrant or production order seeking personal information in their records about third parties. The Court found that an organization in this situation has standing — and potentially a duty — to challenge the order if it constitutes an undue interference with the privacy interests of the third parties. The decision underscores the importance of obtaining legal advice before responding to such a request, to assist in determining whether the order should be challenged. The decision is particularly important for financial institutions, health