The recent Supreme Court decision in Royal Bank of Canada v. Trang has provided
important guidance on how Canada's federal privacy legislation,
the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents
Act ("PIPEDA"), is to be interpreted. To the
relief of judgment creditors across the country, the Supreme Court
ruled that courts can use their inherent jurisdiction to make
orders permitting the disclosure of personal information, including
personal information contained in mortgage discharge statements,
and that such disclosures are permitted based on the implied
consent of the mortgagor.
RBC was a judgment creditor of Phat and Phoung Trang and sought
a sheriff's sale of their Toronto property. The sheriff
required a mortgage discharge statement from Scotiabank, the Trangs
mortgagee, in order to sell the property and determine the rights
of both Scotiabank and RBC to the proceeds of sale. RBC was unable
to obtain the mortgage discharge statement from the Trangs