The Supreme Court of Canada has advanced both defamation law and
Internet law in its recent decision in Crookes v
Newton,1 released on October 19, 2011. The court,
by a majority of six judges, held that a person cannot defame
someone merely by publishing a hyperlink to a third party's
website or document containing defamatory material: "... a
hyperlink by itself, should never be seen as a
'publication' of the content to which it
refers."2 "Making reference to the existence
and/or location of content by hyperlink or otherwise, without more,
is not publication of that content."3
The majority compares hyperlinks to footnoted references in a
paper document. Even though hyperlinks, unlike footnotes, offer
immediate access to the third-party sites to which they refer,
readers know that in following the link they are being referred to
a different source. The majority expressly refrains from deciding
whether the conclusion should be different in the case of embedded
or