Introduction
In 1182573 B.C. Ltd. v Gerber,1 the British Columbia Court of Appeal provided one of the most detailed judicial warnings about generative AI in litigation yet seen from a British Columbian court. This bulletin summarizes the decision, examines the Court’s observations and the reasoning underlying them, and considers the implications for the future of generative AI in legal practice in Canada.
Although the decision arose in the context of a self-represented litigant, the Court made clear that its warnings apply with equal force to members of the legal profession.
The Underlying Dispute
The proceeding arose from a contractual dispute over a purchase and sale agreement for waterfront property in Halfmoon Bay, British Columbia. The Appellants, self-represented by their sole director and shareholder (the “Company Director”), appealed orders requiring the Appellants to post security for costs and to reduce the scope of their notices to admit. Justice Griffin held that both