Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 27 MAY 2015

When "Don't Tell The Other Side" Creates An Ethical Problem

I recently sat on a panel of mediators discussing ethics and mediations. As mediators, we all know that when a party says "don't tell the other side" of such and such, we can't and we don't. But are there situations where the non-disclosure is so fundamental that the mediator should withdraw from the mediation?

CanadaLitigation, Mediation & Arbitration

I recently sat on a panel of mediators discussing ethics and mediations. As mediators, we all know that when a party says "don't tell the other side" of such and such, we can't and we don't. But are there situations where the non-disclosure is so fundamental that the mediator should withdraw from the mediation?

Take a simple example. Counsel acts for the plaintiff on a wrongful dismissal. By the time of the mediation, his client has not found employment. In caucus, she says: "But I do have an offer – my lawyer told me not to accept it until after the mediation." Counsel pipes up: "You can't tell them that!"

The mediators on the panel discussed variations of this theme. To my surprise, some of my colleagues were strongly of the view that the failure to disclose amounted, effectively, to a misrepresentation by omission which, if not corrected, would force them to withdraw from the mediation. Since most mediators are lawyers, the argument went, we are officers of the

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from