The collateral fact rule is often misunderstood. As indicated by
the Ontario Court of Appeal in R. v. A.C., 2018 ONCA 333, the collateral fact
rule has "historically suffered from confusion in its
application".
In R. v. A.C., the Court of Appeal noted that the
collateral fact rule operates to prevent a party from calling
extrinsic contradictory evidence solely to undermine the
credibility of an opposing party's witness in relation to a
collateral issue.
The extrinsic evidence must be relevant to some issue in the
case other than merely to contradict the witness, as stated by the
Court of Appeal in R. v. G.P., [1996] O.J. No. 4286 (C.A.).
The rule is based in trial efficiency and seeks to avoid
confusing the jury and wasting time with the sub-litigation of
non-essential issues.