Over the past decade, nothing has led to more spilled ink than
the standard of review Canadian courts should apply when reviewing
administrative decision making. Should the court show deference to
the tribunal interpreting its governing statute? Does the case
raise legal questions beyond the expertise of the decision maker,
such that only courts should decide them?
In 2008, the Supreme Court of Canada clarified the standard of
judicial review in Dunsmuir v. New Brunswick 2008 sec 9.
But Dunsmuir led to uncertainty with age. Canadian courts
began applying reasonableness review routinely, treating it like a
"rubber stamp."
So it is no surprise that the Supreme Court of Canada took the
opportunity to focus the standard of review landscape in two
companion decisions in late 2019, Canada (Minister of
Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov 2019 sec 65, and
Bell Canada v. Canada (AG) 2019 sec 66 (collectively,
Vavilov).