Recent News ReLeases have explored arguments made by tenants who
failed to pay rent during the COVID-19 pandemic; more specifically,
how the Courts applied force majeure clauses to rent
obligations. In this instalment, a fitness club tenant claimed that
it was relieved of its obligation to pay rent during
provincially-mandated closures. The Ontario Superior Court followed
ample previous authority to hold that force majeure
clauses cannot be used to avoid paying rent unless the terms of the
clause expressly say so.
Now, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruling has muddied the
waters.
Lower Court Favoured the Landlord
In Niagara Falls Shopping Centre Inc v. LAF Canada Co.,
the tenant operated a fitness gym from leased premises. When the
tenant was forced to close due to the Ontario government's
mandated closures, the parties entered into a rent relief/deferral
agreement with respect to the rent payable for April to June, 2020.
After the agreement expired, the tenant