The Supreme Court of Canada has struck down the
mandatory victim surcharge in section 737 of the Criminal
Code on the grounds that it is a cruel and unusual punishment
prohibited by section 12 of the Charter. This is an
important decision that could impact the constitutional validity of
other mandatory minimum sentences.
The victim surcharge required everyone who was
discharged, pled guilty to, or was found guilty of an offence under
the Criminal Code or the Controlled Drugs and
Substances Act to pay an amount equal to 30% of any fine
imposed, or where no fine was imposed, $100 for each offence
punishable by summary conviction and $200 for each offence
punishable by indictment. Consequences for a failure to pay
the surcharge included the threat of imposition of a deemed period
of imprisonment, and committing the offender for non-payment
without a reasonable excuse.