The general rule upon completion of litigation is that the
successful party is entitled to its costs: Rule 14-1(9). Typically
the costs recovered by a successful litigant represent only a small
fraction of the actual legal costs incurred by that party. In some
circumstances, increased costs are available. Historically, where a
party engaged in reprehensible conduct, special costs could be
awarded by the courts as a punitive measure, to express the
court's rebuke and disapproval of the misconduct.
Over time, the courts did not consistently treat the issue of
whether special costs could be awarded as a result of conduct that
took place prior to the commencement of legal proceedings. To
address the inconsistency, in Smithies Holdings Inc. v. RCV Holding
Ltd., 2017 BCCA 177, ("Smithies"), the BC Court of Appeal
established a new "bright line rule" that pre-litigation
conduct should not be considered in determining whether an award of
special costs is appropriate, because: