On April 25, 2019, the Federal Court of Appeal issued its
decision in a longstanding patent dispute in the oil patch
regarding hydraulic fracturing technology: Packers Plus Energy
Services Inc. and Rapid Completions LLC v.
Essential Energy Services Ltd. et al, 2019 FCA 96. In
support of its patent, Packers had issued a series of infringement
suits against several players in the Canadian oil industry,
including Baker Hughes Canada and Weatherford.
In a unanimous decision of the three member panel, the Federal
Court of Appeal denied the appeal of Packers Plus Energy Services
Inc. ("Packers") and Rapid Completions
LLC (collectively, the "Appellants")
from a trial decision dismissing Packers' claim of infringement
and instead invalidating its Canadian Patent No. 2,412,072 (the
"Patent") on the basis of anticipation
and obviousness (2017 FC 1111). The Appellate Court upheld the
Trial Court's finding of invalidity on the basis of
obviousness, finding it unnecessary to