On March 9, 2020 the Ontario Court of Appeal released its
decision in Reddock v. Canada, a class action
brought on behalf of inmates who were subject to prolonged solitary
confinement in federal prisons. In a unanimous decision, Justices
Sharpe, Juriansz, and Trotter upheld Justice Perell's $20
million award of Charter damages in favour of class members, which
is the first of its kind in Canada. This decision confirms that
Canada is liable to pay these damages for its "clear
disregard" for the class members' Charter rights, but
reverses the systemic negligence finding that was the second basis
for the damages award in the court below.
This decision provides useful guidance on the availability of
Charter and systemic negligence damages in cases where
governments know or ought to have known that the implementation of
legislative power could cause serious harm.