Butterfield v Intact Insurance Company, 2022 ONSC 4060,
Affirmed 2023 ONCA 246
Brett Butterfield suffered a psychotic episode while at a
firearms store that ended with him stabbing the owner in the neck
with a large knife. He was charged with aggravated assault, but was
found not criminally responsible due to his schizophrenia.
The owner sued Mr Butterfield in negligence, arguing it was
reasonably foreseeable that he might have a psychotic episode
before or after he acquired his firearms license and hurt
someone.
Mr Butterfield held a Condominium Unit Owners Policy with Intact
Insurance Company at the time of the attack that included
third-party liability coverage up to $2MM. So upon receiving the
lawsuit, he asked them to defend and indemnify him.