On October 21, 2021, the Supreme Court of Canada
in Nelson (City) v Marchi, 2021 SCC
41, affirmed British Columbia's Court of Appeal
decision and ordered a new trial to determine the standard of care
of the City of Nelson (the "City") in a
negligence lawsuit brought by Ms. Taryn Joy Marchi
("Marchi").
Facts
Since 2000, the City relied on a policy for street and sidewalks
snow removal ("Policy"). The Policy sets
priorities for several areas, including the downtown core, but did
not specifically mention clearing parking stalls or creating
snowbanks. In addition to the Policy, the City also has several
unwritten practices that include clearing the streets first and
removing the snow after all snow plowing is completed. The City
experienced a heavy snowfall on January 4th and 5th, 2015. On
January 6, 2015, Marchi injured her leg as she attempted to cross a
snowbank created by the City's employees when clearing snow in
angled parking stalls on Baker Street, located