In a decision released on July 18, 2019, Canada's top court
granted leave to appeal in yet another case involving the
controversial and sometimes nebulous concept of good faith in the
performance of a contract. Just last month, the Supreme Court of
Canada granted leave to appeal from the Ontario Court of
Appeal's decision on contractual good faith in CM Callow v.
Zollinger (See our article
here). And, this month, the SCC agreed to hear an appeal from
the British Columbia Court of Appeal's decision in Greater Vancouver
Sewerage and Drainage District v. Wastech Services Ltd.
regarding whether there is an obligation to exercise discretion
under a contract in good faith.
In the Greater Vancouver v. Wastech case, a contractor
hired to transport solid waste alleged that the Vancouver Sewerage
and Drainage District had allocated wastes between long-haul and
short-haul destinations in bad faith and thus increased
Wastech's costs by millions of dollars. An arbitrator of