Can a defendant use the findings from an investigation on the
scope of a cyber-attack to oppose certification of a data breach
class action? In Kaplan v. Casino Rama Services
Inc., 2018 ONSC 3545, the Ontario Superior Court said
yes, but there may be a waiver of privilege in doing so.
In Kaplan, the defendant sent notice of a breach to
approximately 200,000 individuals potentially affected by a
cyber-attack. In the ensuing class action, the plaintiff proposed
to argue at certification that the 200,000 people provided with
notice could serve as a "proxy" for the definition of the
class at certification. In response, the defendant delivered
an affidavit that referred to findings of the expert it had hired
to investigate the attack. The expert concluded that not all of the
individuals who had received notice of the breach were actually
affected and, in fact, the number of affected individuals was
less.