In the motion decision in Trumble v. Soomal, a
2020 decision, the Court addresses productions in a personal injury
action and the plaintiff's affidavit of documents.
This decision starts off with a sentiment that as defence
counsel, I have been dealing with routinely:
It is unfortunate that, in 2020, the case law on the issue
of production of somewhat routine medical and work records in
personal injury litigation has not been more definitively decided,
at least on the case law referred to before me.
I have started to receive some very deficient affidavits of
documents by the plaintiff which only reference the invoices for
medical records, with the message that if the defendant wants the
plaintiff's productions, they will have to pay for the actual
productions in advance. Although I take the position that if the
plaintiff intends to rely on the documents at trial, they are
required to produce said documents, at their own expense,
inevitably this back and forth