When an administrative tribunal interprets its governing
statute, this usually raises a question of law. The tribunal
is engaged in an exercise of statutory interpretation, something
Canadian Courts do with aplomb. So when the
tribunal's analysis of the language or application of
legislation is challenged on appeal, should the Courts nonetheless
defer to that analysis? A recent decision of the
Ontario Court of Appeal answers this question in the
affirmative.
The Tribunal's Ruling on the Retrospective Application of
its Legislation
CNH Canada Ltd. v. Chesterman Farm Equipment Ltd., 2018
ONCA 637, involved a statutory appeal from an order of the
Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs Tribunal (the
"Tribunal").