Defendants and insurers are sometimes criticized if they refuse
to offer a monetary amount to settle an action. However, a recent
court decision shows that they should not fear doing so if their
position is supportable.
In Mundinger
v. Ashton, 2020 ONSC 2024, Justice Charney referred to an
Ontario Court of Appeal decision, wherein it was stated:
"Under our system defendants are entitled to put the plaintiff
to the proof, and there is no obligation to settle an
action".
Following an 11 day jury trial resulting from an automobile
accident, the plaintiff was awarded zero after applying the
deductible and deducting collateral benefits. The defendant sought
costs of $160,000 all-inclusive.