The City of Hamilton has been busy recently at the Ontario Court
of Appeal, acting as appellant on two separate appeals relating to
findings of liability for non-repair of intersections. The City was
found partly at fault at the trial level in both actions, on
similar facts.
Although the two appeals, Chiocchio v. Hamilton (City),
2018 ONCA 762, and Smith v. Safranyos, 2018 ONCA 760,
deal with similar fact scenarios, they were heard by separate
panels.
Given that the panels came to different conclusions on liability
against the City on similar facts, one queries whether the results
would have been different were the appeals argued together.
Read together, we are left with some guidance on how the Courts
will address municipal liability in the context of allegations of
non-repair. The distinction between the facts in this case,
however, provide lower courts with little guidance on how to
determine when a municipality has failed in its duty to ensure