A recent Ontario Superior Court of Justice case, Desrochers
(Litigation guardian of) v. McGinnis [2022] O.J. No. 3891,
revisited the principles of proving negligence in a case where the
plaintiff, Megan Desrochers, was injured while operating the
defendants' all-terrain vehicle (ATV). (For link to part one of
this series, see below).
Standard of care
The real issue in this case is whether any of the defendants
breached the standard of care. The general approach to determining
the appropriate standard of care is found in Ryan v. Victoria
(City) [1999] 1 S.C.R. 201 at para. 28:
Conduct is negligent if it creates an objectively unreasonable
risk of harm. To avoid liability, a person must exercise the
standard of care that would be expected of an ordinary, reasonable
and prudent person in the same circumstances. The measure of what
is reasonable depends on the facts of each case, including the
likelihood of a known or foreseeable harm, the gravity of that
harm,