Many employers now have a practice of not giving employment
references at all. That can prevent future employers from finding
out about very serious misconduct. It is arguably an excessive
reaction to a concern about possible defamation claims by the
departed employee. A recent Ontario case is weighty on this topic
because the decision at trial was approved by the Ontario Court of
Appeal and leave was denied by the Supreme Court of Canada.
In Kanak v. Riggin, an employee was hired subject to a
positive reference check. When the new employer checked with the
former manager, he said the following:
- There was a lot of conflict between
Ms. Kanak, her supervisor and other employees;