On August 17, 2018, in Azar v. Strada Crush Limited, 2018 ONSC
4763, Morgan J. certified a class action under Ontario's
Employment Standards Act, 2000
("ESA").
The plaintiff alleged that the defendant breached s.
22(1) of the ESA for failing to pay employees
overtime pay when they worked for more than 44 hours per week and
s. 24(1) of the ESA for failing to pay employees
holiday pay. The defendant argued that it fell within various
regulatory exceptions to both provisions. Following significant
scrutiny of the proposed common issues that contained "as much
advocacy as inquiry", Morgan J. certified the case. As in
previous employment class actions, the critical question became
whether only "superficial commonality" existed on the
record before the court.