In Lipson v Cassels Brock & Blackwell LLP, 2019
ONSC 5483, 148 O.R. (3d) 146, a class action by investors against a
law firm, Justice Perell revisits the law of privilege, but in the
context of the internal workings of a law firm. The issue before
him was the following: were the communications arising from a
partner seeking the advice of the firm's Ethics and Standards
Committee producible?
After reviewing the communications in issue, Justice Perell
found that they were irrelevant. Nonetheless, he went on and
examined whether or not a claim for privilege could be sustained if
he had found otherwise. The basis advanced for the claim of
privilege was that the communications satisfied the test for
"quality assurance privilege". This privilege appears to
be used by the medical profession for hospitals. The issue in
Lipson was whether lawyers may have a case-by-case
privilege based on the circumstances of their examining or
inquiring about the quality of their own legal