The Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) recently provided
municipalities and lower courts guidance in applying the "core
policy defence", in Nelson (City) v Marchi, 2021 SCC
41. The Court has constricted the scope of this defence.
Municipalities often use the core-policy defence to shield
themselves from liability for negligence. The basis for the defence
is that core-policy government decisions made by democratically
elected officials (or their associates) should remain free from
judicial supervision. Core-policy immunity is to protect the
legislative branch's independence and the separation of
powers.
Unlike core-policy decisions, operational decisions made by
municipalities will face the private law principles of negligence.
The SCC has defined operational decisions as the practical
implementation of formulated policies. Such operational decisions
are generally "made on the basis of administrative direction,
expert or professional opinion, technical standards or