When conducting an examination for discovery, counsel should
keep in mind that the Rules of Civil Procedure are
designed to provide parties with full disclosure of information in
order to avoid surprise.
However, as demonstrated in Beemer and Chrysler v. 1350246 Ontario
Inc., 2020 ONSC 5564 ("Beemer"), there
are limits on the scope of discovery. This case addresses a
hypothetical question that was posed to the defendant's witness
on discovery.
The Action
Beemer involved a personal injury action commenced by
the plaintiff, David Beemer, and his wife, Lee Chrysler, resulting
from an ATV accident that occurred on October 16, 2017. Mr. Beemer
alleges that he was driving the ATV when the front left wheel came
off the axle, causing him to lose control of the vehicle and
sustain injuries.