2011 ONCA 331 (Released April 29, 2011)
Solicitor's Negligence – Costs –
Contractual Interpretation
In this decision, the Court of Appeal affirmed that a cause of
action for solicitor's negligence is assignable. As part of a
plan of arrangement of Royal Trust, Gentra Canada Investments Inc.
("Gentra") was assigned a mortgage.
Gentra brought an action against Lipson and his firm alleging
breach of contract and negligence due to alleged deficiencies in
mortgage documents prepared by Lipson while he was counsel for
Royal Trust.
Gentra brought a motion for partial summary judgment to confirm
its right to pursue the action. Lipson asserted by way of a
cross-motion that an action for solicitor's negligence is
non-assignable as a matter of public policy. The court held that a
cause of action for solicitor's negligence is assignable if an
assignee can show a legitimate commercial interest in the cause of
action against the lawyer. It rejected the contention that such