A recent arbitration decision provides insight into what
constitutes reasonable discipline in response to a failure by a
teacher to participate in an investigation.
In Ontario English Catholic Teachers' Association v
Brant Haldimand Norfolk Catholic District School Board, 2019
CanLII 95001 (ON LA), the union grieved the unpaid suspension of a
teacher who failed to answer questions during an investigation into
allegations that he engaged in misconduct involving two female
grade six students. The school board received a complaint that the
teacher had engaged in various inappropriate conduct, including:
grabbing a student's bra strap and placing a piece of brown
paper towel underneath it; massaging a student's shoulders;
asking why a student smelled so good; telling a student that he had
a picture of her in his bedroom; using a highlighter to paint a
student's fingernails; and tapping a student on her leg.