Would an insured's psychotic episode, resulting in a
stabbing, warrant coverage for a negligence claim brought by the
victim of the stabbing?
In Butterfield v Intact Insurance Company, 2022 ONSC
4060, the Superior Court of Justice confirmed that an insurer
correctly denied coverage under the exclusionary clause of an
insurance policy to its insured who suffered a psychotic episode
and stabbed another person.
The Facts
The Applicant, Brett Butterfield ("B") attended at a
firearms store in 2019. He experienced a deluded belief that the
store owner had murdered his friend, causing him to stab the store
owner.
B was charged with aggravated assault but was declared Not
Criminally Responsible ("NCR") on account of his
schizophrenia.