On November 28, 2025, the Divisional Court released Caledon
Residences Inc. v. Ontario Land Tribunal, 2025 ONSC 6546. Justice Backhouse, writing for
a unanimous panel, confirmed that parties challenging Ontario Land
Tribunal ("OLT") decisions on questions
of law, including alleged breaches of procedural fairness, must
pursue the statutory appeal route, which requires leave.
Background
Caledon Residences Inc. ("CRI"), was
party to OLT appeals brought by 1685078 Ontario Inc.
("Sunshine Group") respecting
applications for draft plan of subdivision ("Draft
Plan") approval and a zoning by-law amendment
("ZBA"). CRI raised no issues with the
ZBA. Instead, it sought to secure a condition of draft plan
approval requiring Sunshine Group to share in the costs of certain
infrastructure from which CRI alleged Sunshine Group benefited.
Days before the hearing, Sunshine Group and the Town of Caledon
entered Minutes of Settlement pursuant to which Sunshine Group
withdrew its