The decision of Justice Handrigan in Ryan v. Curlew is
the first motor vehicle accident personal injury decision to come
out of the Newfoundland and Labrador courts in quite some time. The
case is a win for the insurance industry in many respects.
The accident occurred on Pitts Memorial Drive in 2010. At that
time, Ryan was a 27 year old Ship's Clerk with no pre-existing
injuries. Her claim for over $3 million was for total disability
due to chronic headaches, persistent neck, back and shoulder pain
with depression, anxiety and PTSD. The Defendant was found liable
for the accident and Handrigan J. awarded $803,420 in damages,
broken down as follows:
The Court awarded $100,000 in general damages, less than was
expected for a total disability. This was largely due to issues
with Ms. Ryan's credibility, with the Court finding her claim
of total disability to be "disingenuous and
unconvincing." Handrigan J. emphasized the importance of a
Plaintiff's credibility in soft