Courts have begun to criticize plaintiff lawyers who file
multiple overlapping class actions across the country. In Ontario,
Perell J. refused to approve an agreement by two BC firms to share
their fee with a Saskatchewan-based firm, Merchant Law Group
("MLG") in Bancroft-Snell v. Visa Canada
Corporation. More than one year after the BC firms had filed
class actions in Ontario and BC alleging conspiracies in relation
to credit card interchange fees, MLG started copycat actions in
Alberta and Saskatchewan. The BC firms agreed to pay a share of
their fee to MLG in return for MLG agreeing to stay its
actions.
In a hard-hitting judgment, Perell J. described the fee sharing
agreement as "ransom fee" that was unenforceable and
possibly illegal. MLG's legal services were "useless to
the client"; it "did not make a contribution to the
achievement of the settlement agreement and should not share in the
recovery". He described MLG's late filing of class actions
as "suspect":