Parties to class action settlements often settle, at least in
part, to avoid the ordinary uncertainty of litigation. Courts have
long emphasized that while they retain discretion to supervise
payments of lawyers’ fees as part of a settlement, the
settlement approval process will not entail the Court re-writing a
settlement that it is not prepared to approve.
The Court of Appeal for Ontario’s decision in Welsh v Ontario exemplifies this
tradition. The Court overturned a motion judge’s settlement
approval order which imposed a settlement term to which neither
party had agreed and which, the Court said, significantly altered
the terms of the bargain between the parties. Perell J. had been
critical of the merits of the settlement, which would effectively
leave 90% of class members without compensation. Although he
ultimately approved the settlement, Perell J. purported to use his
supervisory authority under the Class Proceedings Act to
approve the settlement but direct