Ontario Court Rejects Notion that Class Members
Must Be "Clones."
Judges on a certification
motion do understand that class members are not clones and even if
they were clones, judges understand that individual clones may have
had different experiences with the defendant. Commonality is not
disapproved by finding instances of
difference.1
The Supreme Court of Canada has described the "commonality
requirement" as the central notion of a class action –
in order to be certified (i.e. allowed to proceed to a decision on
the merits), a class action must raise common issues of fact or law
for the class. To be a common issue, the answers to the questions
raised by the issue must be capable of extrapolation, in the same
manner, to each member of the class. An issue is not common if its
resolution is dependent upon individual findings for each class
member.