Justice Rady of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (London)
has dismissed a proposed class action against Eastern Platinum Ltd.
(Eastplats) and certain of its former directors, finding, among
other things, that that there was no reasonable possibility that
the proposed plaintiff would succeed on his alleged claims. This is
the first Ontario decision considering the test for leave to
commence a secondary market securities class action since the
Supreme Court of Canada released its decision in
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v.
Green (Green) in December of 2015.
Eastplats asserted on the leave motion that the proposed action
did not meet either branch of the test for granting leave to
commence a claim for misrepresentation in the secondary market
under the
Securities Act (Ontario) (the OSA), which
requires a proposed plaintiff to demonstrate that the claim is
brought in good faith and has a "reasonable possibility of
success." The proposed plaintiff's