In Maginnis and Magnaye v. FCA
Canada et al, 2020 ONSC 5462, the court refused to certify
a class proceeding for the reason that there was no evidence that
the plaintiffs had actually been harmed. A defendant was repairing
the allegedly defective vehicles at issue and there was no evidence
that the plaintiffs would have any harm to compensate after the
repairs were implemented.
The plaintiffs sought certification of a class of owners and
lessees of certain diesel-engine vehicles. The plaintiffs alleged
that the vehicles had emissions defeat devices (i.e., an
emissions control system that would make the vehicle appear
compliant with emission regulations when it was not). At least two other emissions defeat device
class actions had been certified in Ontario.