2010 SCC 21, released 10 June 2010
Constitutional Law – Mandatory Publication
Bans at Bail Hearings do not Infringe the Freedom of Expression
Guarantee under the Charter
This appeal, which arose in the context of two high-profile
cases in Alberta and Ontario, involved a consideration of the
constitutionality of s. 517 of the Criminal Code. The
appellant media organizations argued that the provision is an
unjustifiable violation of the Charter's freedom of expression
guarantee because it provides for a mandatory publication ban of
the evidence and information produced at a bail hearing if
requested by the accused.
In an 8–1 decision, the Supreme Court of Canada upheld
the constitutionality of s. 517 under the Oakes test.
Parliament's pressing and substantial objective was to both
ensure expeditious bail hearings and to safeguard an accused's
right to a fair trial. The s. 517 mandatory publication ban is
rationally connected to this objective because it prevents