Introduction – A sound plan with a flawed execution
In January 2025, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled on the case
of Pyxis Real Estate Equities Inc. v. Attorney General of
Canada, 2025 ONCA 65, effectively overturning the decision of
the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in 2024 ONSC 2039. This case
involves Mr. Jubb and his four corporations. The corporate
structure is completely vertical, where a corporation is the sole
shareholder of the corporation below it, and Mr. Jubb, at the top,
owns 100% of Holdco and so on.
Mr. Jubb asked his accountants to devise a strategy that would
allow him to pay off the shareholder loan he owed to Holdco and leave
the remaining balance to him, all on a tax-free basis. The
accountants came up with a plan that involved Pyxis, the
corporation at the bottom of the chain, paying tax-free capital dividends to its sole corporate
shareholder, and the capital dividends moving up the chain one by
one to reach Mr. Jubb. The intended amount