Whether civil jury trials should stay or go is a question that
has confronted the legal community for some time now. In the
current legal landscape, where COVID-19 plays a significant factor
in these decisions, this has garnered increased attention
from
civil litigators and courts alike.
The Ontario Court of Appeal recently discussed the striking of
jury notices and proceeding by way of a judge-alone trial.
In
Belton v Spencer, a personal injury action, the appellant
moved under Rule 63.02(1)(b) of the Rules of Civil
Procedure for an order staying the order of Justice
Sheard that struck out the parties' jury notices.
The action was originally placed on the trial list for November
2018. In November 2019, the trial adjourned to commence in October
2020. The COVID-19 pandemic hit Ontario in March 2020, at which
time the Superior Court of Justice restricted the scope of its
operations. In June 2020, the parties were advised that due to the
pandemic, it was