The “two-step test” for commonality at class action certification—that plaintiffs must demonstrate some basis in fact that the proposed common issues exist and that they are common to the entire class—continues to serve as a focus of debate. Much ink has been spilled about this issue1.
Perhaps until now. In Noramco LLC v. British Columbia2 and McKinsey & Company, Inc. United States v. British Columbia3, the British Columbia Court of Appeal recently confirmed that whether courts describe the inquiry as one-or two-step is a distraction that is ultimately immaterial. The approach to commonality in British Columbia remains a functional one that requires plaintiffs to establish a minimum evidentiary foundation supporting the existence of some basis in fact of a common issue.