Courts have been hesitant to find a defendant liable for damages
caused by the intentional tort of a third party. This notion was
reinforced in Teglas v. City of Brantford et al,
2020 ONSC 7408 ("Teglas"), a case which involved
an assault in a parking garage.
Justice Turnball found that even though the owner of the parking
garage and a security company breached a duty of care owed to the
plaintiff, the breach did not cause the plaintiff's
damages.
The Action
Teglas involved a personal injury action commenced by
the plaintiff, Mihaly Teglas, arising from an unprovoked assault by
two unidentified assailants in the stairwell of a parkade on
February 24, 2012.
Mr. Teglas alleges that the defendants, The Corporation of the
City of Brantford (the "City"), and Romex Security Inc.
("Romex Security"), were negligent for their failure to
take proper security measures to keep the parkade safe for
customers.