Is the plaintiff in a medical malpractice case required to
disprove every possible theory or potential non-negligent cause of
injury?
The Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC") considered this
issue when it heard Armstrong v Ward, 2021 SCC 1 on January 18, 2021.
In February 2010, the plaintiff underwent a colectomy (colon
removal procedure). The surgery was conducted by the defendant, a
general surgeon. The surgery was conducted laparoscopically,
meaning it was performed in the abdomen by making small incisions
and inserting a laparoscope which lets the surgical team view the
affected area from a distance using cameras and screens in the
operating room. The surgery appeared to go smoothly – there
were no signs that the plaintiff had been injured during or
immediately following the procedure. However, the plaintiff began
experiencing continual pain after the surgery. Weeks later, it was
discovered that her left ureter was blocked, which caused damage to
her left kidney,