In Ontario, in order to be successful in a medical negligence action, a plaintiff must
prove a number of elements, including that the health care provider
breached the standard of care of a prudent and reasonable
practitioner in the circumstances, and that the breach of the
standard of care caused, on the balance of probabilities, the harm
suffered by the plaintiff.
Health care providers obligation to exercise reasonable
clinical judgment
It is well accepted that a health care provider is not held to a
standard of perfection. The standard is that of a reasonable and
prudent physician in the circumstances. If a physician has
reasonably exercised their clinical judgment, but that has resulted
in an adverse outcome for the plaintiff, then there is no
liability. The courts have opined that a physician should not be
liable for "a mere error in judgment". The courts,
however, have recognized that the proper exercise of clinical
judgment requires weighing, assessing and