A Rare Decertification Decision From The BCCA Stands: No Leave To Appeal Wakelam

The Supreme Court of Canada yesterday refused the plaintiff's application for leave to appeal the British Columbia Court of Appeal's decertification decision in Wakelam v. Wyeth et al.  Wakelam is a claim against various manufacturers of children's cough and cold medication for relief due to the manufacturers' sale of the medicines prior to a Health Canada order requiring such medicines not be marketed for children under six years of age and requiring re-labelling to that effect.  The case was certified in 2011.

Early this year, the British Columbia Court of Appeal made the rare (in B.C.) order to decertify the case.  In reaching this decision, the Court made two findings of particular interest to class action defendants: that the plaintiffs failed to make out their main claims pursuant to the "reasonable cause of action" requirement; and that both the Business Practices and Consumer Protection Act and Competition Act provide a "complete code" such that marrying the