Lloyd's Underwriters v. Blue Mountain Log Sales Ltd., 2016
BCCA 352
When does an insurer's duty to defend arise? More
specifically, does it arise before the insurer is given notice of
the claim? That is the fundamental question addressed by this
case.
Background
The factual background is as follows. Certain members of the
Clarke Group of companies, manufacturers of goods in Canada and the
United States, were sued in Washington State by the Global Group.
In August, 2013, the Clarke Group tendered its defence to its
American insurer, which defended under a reservation of rights.
Several months later, the Global Group added claims against
Canadian members of the Clarke Group, however, the latter did not
initially realize that this would trigger coverage with Lloyd's
Underwriters, insurers of the Canadian members. As a result, it was
not until April, 2014, that Lloyd's was asked to defend.
Lloyd's assumed the defence, retaining counsel already acting
for the Clarke