The recent costs endorsement in Hoang v. The Personal
Insurance Co.1 provides policyholders with a
succinct reminder of the general rule that a policyholder is
entitled to full indemnity costs where an insurer wrongfully denies
its obligation to provide coverage.
The underlying action arose as a result of injuries sustained by
a minor pedestrian, Christopher Hoang, when he was struck by a
motor vehicle shortly after being dropped off on a city sidewalk by
his father. A claim was commenced against the driver of the vehicle
and against Christopher's father, Mr. Hoang. A jury found that
the driver of the vehicle that struck Christopher was not
negligent. It found that Mr. Hoang negligently caused or
contributed to the accident and his son's injuries by selecting
an unsuitable choice of unloading area.